By Ken Reed
The Huffington Post
September 13, 2013
The ongoing debate about whether or not fighting should be part of hockey often seems to just go in circles. No doubt there’s plenty of passion on the issue. Both the fighting advocates — who contend fighting is a necessary, self-policing, aspect of the game — and fighting antagonists — who believe fighting in sports is barbaric and has no place in hockey — intensely defend their positions. Emotion rules the day.
So, in thinking about this issue, and the emotional tension surrounding it, I thought a new approach might be to let medical doctors share their perspectives on the issue. So, to that end, here we go …
Dr. Michael J. Stuart, is an orthopedic surgeon at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota and chief medical officer for USA Hockey.
“If we truly want to make every effort to reduce the risk of concussion in the sport of ice hockey, we should eliminate fighting,” says Stuart. “There’s no doubt about that.”
Dr. Charles H. Tator, a neurosurgeon and researcher at Toronto Western Hospital who directs programs to reduce head and spinal-cord injuries in sports, concurs.
“We in science can dot the line between blows to the head, brain degeneration and all of these other issues,” according to Tator. “So, in my view, it’s time for the leagues to acknowledge this serious issue and take steps to reduce blows to the brain.”
Those steps, he said, include “getting fighting out of the game.”
“I think it [fighting] should be 100 percent banned,” says Dr. Ricardo Komotar, assistant professor of clinical neurology surgery at the University of Miami School of Medicine. “It’s clearly unnecessary violence. Fighting is something you can obviously eliminate immediately.
“When you’re talking about eliminating head blows in football, you’re kind of limited on what you can do without completely changing the sport. Fighting in hockey seems like something that you could eliminate without changing the sport at all. You could make a big change, I think, without really altering the fundamentals of the game.”
Dr. Robert Cantu is co-director of the Boston University Center for the Study of Traumatic Encephalopathy. He believes that, ultimately, the NHL will be compelled to do away with fighting.
“In my opinion, they’re just turning their eyes away from a problem they don’t want to address right now,” says Cantu. “Eventually, they’ll address it … The sheer volume of cases (supporting a link between blows to the head and chronic brain disease) I think is going to just overwhelm anybody that wants to be in denial about the existence of this problem.”
Dr. Michael Cusimano, a neurosurgeon at St. Michael’s Hospital in Toronto who is involved in efforts to reduce sports injuries, criticizes the N.H.L. for saying it needs more data.
“We heard this about 40 years ago with cigarette smoking,” Cusimano said. “Sure, there can be more evidence, but there’s some evidence out there that fighting is clearly a cause of brain injuries. What’s the threshold of evidence that Gary Bettman needs to see this?”
Dr. Rajendra Kale is a neurologist and Editor-in-Chief of the Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ). He wrote an editorial last year saying it’s time to stop the violence and play hockey.
“Supporters of fighting argue that it has always been integral to hockey,” wrote Kale. “This brutal tradition should be given up now that research has shown that repeated head trauma can cause severe progressive brain damage.”
In order to make some progress on this issue, maybe it’s time to move beyond discussions about whether or not fighting is good for the game. Let’s take the human egos out of this debate — on both sides — and listen to the medical professionals who represent the silent human brains inside the heads of the players skating around on the ice.
Ken Reed is Sports Policy Director for League of Fans
Sports Forum Podcast
Episode #32 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: Prolific Author Joe Posnanski Joins the Show – Posnanski is one of America’s best sportswriters and has twice been named the best sports columnist in America by the Associated Press Sports Editors. We chat about his new book, “Why We Love Baseball,” his new Substack newsletter called Joe Blogs, and we cover topics including how baseball treats its fans, MLB’s numerous rule changes this past season, how the sport can become more fan-friendly, the greatness of Negro Leagues champion Buck O’Neil, and much more.
Follow on Facebook: @SportsForumPodcast
Episode #31 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: Foul Ball Safety Is Still an Important Issue at Ballparks – Our guests are Jordan Skopp, founder of FoulBallSafety.com and Greg Wilkowski, a Chicago based attorney. We discuss the historical problem of foul balls injuring fans and why some teams are still hesitant to put up protective netting in some minor league and college baseball parks.
Episode #30 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: The State of College Athletics with Dr. David Ridpath: Problems and Potential Solutions – Ridpath is a sports administration professor at Ohio University and a member of The Drake Group, a college sports reform think tank.
Episode #29 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: The Honorable Tom McMillen Visits League of Fans’ Sports Forum – McMillen is a former All-American basketball player, Olympian, Rhodes Scholar and U.S. Congressman. We discuss the state of college athletics today.
Episode #28 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: A Chat With Mano Watsa, a Leading Basketball and Life Educator – Watsa is President of PGC Basketball, the largest education basketball camp in the world. We discuss problems in youth sports today.
Episode #27 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: Kids’ Sports: How We Can Take Back the Game and Restore Quality Family Time In the Process – Linda Flanagan is author of “Take Back the Game: How Money and Mania Are Ruining Kids’ Sports and Why It Matters.” We discuss how commercialized and professionalized youth sports are hurting kids and their families.
Media"How We Can Save Sports" author Ken Reed appears on Fox & Friends to explain how there's "too much adult in youth sports."
Ken Reed appears on Mornings with Gail from KFKA Radio in Colorado to discuss bad parenting in youth athletics.
“Should College Athletes Be Paid?” Ken Reed on The Morning Show from Wisconsin Public Radio
Ken Reed appears on KGNU Community Radio in Colorado (at 02:30) to discuss equality in sports and Title IX.
Ken Reed appears on the Ralph Nader Radio Hour (at 38:35) to discuss his book The Sports Reformers: Working to Make the World of Sports a Better Place, and to talk about some current sports issues.
- Reed Appears on Ralph Nader Radio Hour League of Fans’ sports policy director, Ken Reed, Ralph Nader and the New York Times’ Tyler Kepner discussed a variety of sports issues on Nader’s radio show as well as Reed’s updated book, How We Can Save Sports: A Game Plan. Reed's book was released in paperback in February, and has a new introduction and several updated sections.
League of Fans is a sports reform project founded by Ralph Nader to fight for the higher principles of justice, fair play, equal opportunity and civil rights in sports; and to encourage safety and civic responsibility in sports industry and culture.
Vanderbilt Sport & Society - On The Ball with Andrew Maraniss with guest Ken Reed, Sports Policy Director for League of Fans and author of How We Can Save Sports: A Game Plan
Sports & Torts – Ken Reed, Sports Policy Director, League of Fans – at the American Museum of Tort Law
Order from Amazon
Order from Amazon
Order from Amazon
Ken Reed’s Author Page on Amazon